DIY walkthrough
How to run a backlink audit
A backlink audit is a review of the sites linking to yours: what's there, which links help, and whether anything needs action. This guide shows how to run one yourself in an afternoon, with Google Search Console and one paid tool.
Updated
Backlink audits are often sold as a monthly service, but most sites need one rarely, and for a specific reason: a manual action notice in Search Console, buying a domain, taking over from a previous SEO provider, or a traffic drop that lines up with a link spam update. Outside those, a quick look at new links once a quarter is plenty.
The steps below use Google Search Console plus one paid index, such as Ahrefs, Semrush or Moz. They end with the disavow decision, which has changed more in recent years than most advice suggests.
When a backlink audit is worth doing
Four situations justify a full audit. A warning from a tool, the most common reason people start one, isn't among them.
| Situation | What to do | Disavow likely? |
|---|---|---|
| A manual action for unnatural links in Search Console | Full audit, remove what you can, disavow the rest, then ask Google to review the site. | Yes |
| Buying a domain or a website | Full audit before you pay. You inherit every link the old owner bought. | Sometimes, for paid links you can't remove |
| Taking over from a previous SEO provider | Audit the links they built, especially if their reports never let you check each one. | Only for a clear pattern of paid or network links |
| A traffic drop that matches a confirmed link spam update | Audit the links, and check other causes such as content or technical changes. | Rarely |
| A tool says you have "toxic" links | A quick look only. Toxicity scores are the tool's own invention. | No |
Google lists its confirmed updates on the Google Search Status Dashboard, so you can check whether a drop lines up with a link spam update. If your previous provider's reporting never listed each link with its web address, the audit is also how you find out what was built.
Pull your links from more than one source
No single tool sees every link, so use two sources:
- Google Search Console: open the Links report and export the external links. This is what Google itself has found.
- One paid index: export the referring domains report from Ahrefs Site Explorer, Semrush Backlink Analytics or Moz Link Explorer.
- Combine them in one spreadsheet and remove duplicates by linking site, not by link.
Working site by site keeps the job small. Tens of thousands of links usually come from a few hundred or a few thousand sites, and a few hundred rows is an afternoon's work.
Want editorial links earned for you? Plans start at $6,000 a month for at least ten.
View pricingSort every linking site into five groups
Five groups cover nearly everything you'll find. Sort by traffic or authority score, give each site a few seconds, and flag only clear problems. Speed matters more than perfection.
| Group | What it looks like | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| Earned coverage | News sites, blogs and resource pages that chose to link to you. | Keep. Note which pages earned them, so you can earn more. |
| Directories and profiles | Business listings, social profiles, review sites. | Leave alone. Harmless in normal numbers. |
| Copies and scrapers | Sites that copied your content or your coverage, links and all. | Ignore. Google already does. |
| Paid or sponsored | Posts you or a provider paid for. | Check they're tagged as paid. If not, ask the site to tag or remove them. |
| Networks and spam | Link networks, link farms, hacked pages with hidden links. | Remove what you can. Disavow only for a manual action or a large pattern. |
For a closer look at any one site, the quality checklist has 12 checks with the tool to use for each. The signs of a network, such as the same template on many sites, no search traffic and links out to lots of unrelated businesses, are covered on our no-PBN link building page.
Toxic backlinks and the disavow decision
Since its December 2022 link spam update, Google has said its systems, including SpamBrain, cancel out spam links automatically. The link stops counting, and your site keeps ranking on its other merits. That leaves two reasons to file a disavow:
- A manual action for unnatural links. Remove what you can, disavow the rest, and send a reconsideration request explaining what you did.
- A history of paid links you can't get removed. The disavow file is insurance.
Otherwise, leave it alone. Disavowing good links can hurt, toxicity lists from tools are unreliable, and Google has said many times that most sites don't need the tool.
If you do file one, keep it simple: a plain text file with one entry per line, using domain: entries (for example domain:example.com) to cover whole sites. Upload it through Search Console's disavow links tool, and keep a dated log of every version, because each upload replaces the last.
Ahrefs, Semrush or Search Console
You don't need every tool. What each one is best at:
- Search Console: free, and the only source that comes from Google. Use it for every audit, and for manual action notices.
- Ahrefs: a large index with clean exports and filters, so you can sort linking sites by traffic and see when links appeared or were lost.
- Semrush: its Backlink Audit tool connects to Search Console, scores each linking site for risk, and can build a disavow file for you.
Treat any risk score as a reason to look, never as an instruction to disavow. The tool can't see what Google already ignores.
Write it up, then plan the links you're missing
A short audit report is enough. Include:
- The date, and the sources you exported.
- How many linking sites fell into each group.
- Every flagged site, with the reason.
- What you did: removal requests sent, sites disavowed, and the disavow file version.
- The date of the next check.
The most useful finding is usually where links are missing, not where they're bad: important pages with a handful of linking sites against competitors with dozens, or whole topics with no coverage at all. Run the same exports on two or three competitors and the gaps are easy to size.
From there the work moves from cleaning up to earning links. Working out how many you need, and what that costs when it's done through news coverage, is covered in our link building packages.
Proof
Links worth keeping look like this.
Real articles from our own studies and client campaigns. In an audit, links like these go in the first group: coverage a publication chose to run.

"Top 10 Haunted Hotels in America." A ranking we built for a client, October 2026.
- Yahoo NewsFederal data shows logging and fishing jobs have highest death ratesClient data story, August 2026
- Cape Towner, South AfricaCastle of Good Hope named among South Africa's most haunted placesClient data story, October 2026
- Star FM, CanadaLotto Max's Luckiest Numbers Revealed Ahead of $50 Million JackpotClient data story, November 2026
It felt closer to digital PR than link buying. Fewer links, better environments, and no pressure to accept placements that did not make sense.
Questions
Questions about backlink audits.
Something we haven't covered? Book a call, or email info@seobacklinks.com and we usually reply within one business day.
What is a backlink audit?
A backlink audit is a review of every site linking to yours, to see which links help, which are harmless and which need action. It ends with a short list of actions, which for most sites is no action at all.
How do I do a backlink audit?
Export your links from Search Console and one paid tool, combine them by linking site, and sort each site into five groups: earned coverage, directories, copies, paid links and spam. Then act only on clear problems, and decide whether a disavow file is needed.
How long does a backlink audit take?
An afternoon for most sites, if you work by linking site rather than by link. Very large sites can review their top few thousand sites by traffic and spot-check the rest, because the spam at the bottom is usually ignored by Google already.
How do I use Semrush's Backlink Audit tool?
Set up a project for your domain, connect Search Console, and let the tool collect your links and score each site for risk. Use the scores to decide what to look at first, then judge each flagged site yourself before disavowing anything.
Can I do a backlink audit with Ahrefs?
Yes. Export the referring domains report from Ahrefs Site Explorer, sort it by traffic, and work through the list in a spreadsheet. Add Search Console's export, because it shows what Google itself has found.
Do I still need to disavow spam links?
Almost never. Google cancels out most spam links without penalizing the site, so the disavow tool is for two cases: recovering from a manual action, and covering paid links you can't get removed.
Can a competitor hurt my site with spam links?
Rarely. Google says its systems ignore such attacks, and that matches what most established sites see. If a sudden wave of spam links appears, keep a record and watch for a manual action before you do anything.
What should a backlink audit report include?
The date and sources, how many linking sites fell into each group, every flagged site with its reason, what you did about it, and the date of the next check. One page is usually enough.
Should I pay for a backlink audit service?
Usually not. Most sites can follow the steps on this page, and outside help mainly makes sense for a manual action or a large site purchase. If you hire someone, ask for the list of flagged sites with reasons, not just a risk score. We don't sell audits: we earn links through news coverage.
How often should I audit my backlinks?
A full audit only when something triggers it, such as a manual action or a domain purchase. Between those, look at your new links once a quarter, and after any traffic drop that matches a Google update.
Start here
Fill the gaps with links worth keeping.
Send your website and the pages you want to rank. We'll suggest stories that could earn them links, and tell you which plan fits.