Practical checklist
How to check backlink quality: the checklist.
A backlink quality checklist tells you whether a link is worth having before you pay for it. These 12 checks show how to check backlink quality: what to look at, which tool to open, and the red flag that means walk away.
Updated
Most bad links are bought on a quick look at one score, such as Domain Rating or Domain Authority. Those scores are easy to pump up. The checks below look at what is hard to fake: real traffic, real writers, the company a site keeps, and where your link actually sits.
You need a browser, a login for Ahrefs or Semrush, and about ten minutes a site. Use the list before you accept a link from any seller, before you write a guest post, and when you review the links you already have. The scoring rules come after the checks, and they are strict on purpose.
The 12 checks and their red flags
The checks come in three groups. Start with checks 1 to 4, which ask whether the site is a real publication. A lot of what link sellers offer fails at this step.
Checks 5 to 8 look at who else the site links to. You can judge a site by the company it keeps, so open recent articles and look at where their links go. Checks 9 to 12 look at the page your link is on, not the whole site.
| Check | How to do it | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Is it in Google? | Search Google for site:example.com, using the site's own address. | Only a handful of results, or no homepage. Google has dropped or filtered the site, and a link there counts for nothing. |
| 2. Does it get traffic? | Open the site in Ahrefs Site Explorer or Semrush Domain Overview and look at the traffic graph. | Little or no traffic from Google, or a sudden drop that never recovered. |
| 3. Does the score match the traffic? | Compare the site's DR or DA score with its traffic. | A high score with almost no visitors. Scores can be pumped up with bought links. Real visitors can't. |
| 4. Do real people write it? | Read the About page and two author pages. | No author names, stock photos as headshots, or a "write for us" page with a price list. |
| 5. Its outgoing links | Note every link to another website in five recent articles. | Links to payday loans, essay writing services or pill shops, in articles about something else. One is a warning. Two means no. |
| 6. Factory-made articles | Skim ten articles and compare how they're built. | Every post is about the same length, with the same headings and one outgoing link in the middle. |
| 7. One clear topic | Read the site's menu and its list of recent posts. | A home improvement blog that also covers crypto, law, fashion and travel. Sites about everything sell links to anyone. |
| 8. How its links are worded | In Ahrefs, open the site's outgoing links and read the clickable words. | Lots of sales phrases such as "best crm software" or "buy gold ira". Journalists don't link like that. Paying customers do. |
| 9. Where the link sits | Find your link on the page. | In the author bio, footer, sidebar or a box marked "partner content". A link inside the article itself carries far more weight. |
| 10. Followed or not | Right-click the link and choose Inspect, or use a browser extension that shows link tags. | A price list that charges more for followed links. That seller is openly selling ranking credit, which Google's rules forbid. |
| 11. Is the article in Google? | Search Google for the article's exact web address a few weeks after it goes live. | It never shows up. Some sellers hide link pages from Google while still charging for them. |
| 12. Is the site's link growth steady? | Open the site's referring domains graph in Ahrefs. | Sharp spikes followed by drops, a sign of links bought and then lost. |
A small local or trade site can pass checks 1 to 4. Size isn't the test. Real readers are.
About check 10: a followed link is a normal link that Google can count as a vote for your page. A nofollow or sponsored tag in the page code asks Google not to count it that way. Big news sites often tag their links, and those links still bring readers, so a tag alone is not a red flag. Paying extra to avoid one is.
How to score the results
Checks 1, 5 and 11 are hard fails. If a site fails any one of them, say no, whatever the price. For the other nine, two red flags mean no.
| Result | What to do |
|---|---|
| No red flags | Fine to accept. |
| One red flag on checks 2 to 4, 6 to 10 or 12 | Look closer, and ask the seller about it before you pay. |
| Two red flags on those checks | Say no. |
| A fail on check 1, 5 or 11 | Say no, at any price. |
A low price never earns a failing site a second chance. Discounts are how failing sites get sold. There is also one signal outside the twelve: a seller who doesn't want you to run these checks has already answered them.
We run checks like these on every link we place, and each link appears in your report with its web address, DA and traffic (see backlink reporting). Our no-PBN policy exists for the same reason: if you can't check a link, don't pay for it.
Want editorial links earned for you? Plans start at $6,000 a month for at least ten.
View pricingQuestions to ask a seller before you pay
- Which sites will my links be on, and can I see them before I pay?
- Do you own or run any of these sites?
- Is the site paid to publish my link?
- Where in the article will the link go?
- What happens if the link or the article is removed?
- What will the report show for each link?
Clear answers to all six are a good sign. Vague answers to the first two usually mean a network. Our guide to PBN links vs editorial links explains what's at stake. Be wary of any marketplace where you pick sites from a price list by authority score: those lists are mostly sites that sell links to anyone.
Checking the links you already have
Once a quarter is enough for most sites, plus any time your traffic drops after a Google update. Export your links from the Links report in Google Search Console, or from Ahrefs, sort them newest first, and run the checks on the sites you don't recognize.
Most failures need no action, because Google already ignores them (our guide to what SEO backlinks are explains which links count). What matters is a pattern: a batch of failing sites from the same seller, or links named in a manual action. That is what a disavow file is for. Our backlink audit guide covers the export, the grouping and the disavow steps.
Proof
Coverage you can check yourself.
Real articles from our own data studies, which rank places by their Google reviews. Run the checklist on any of them. USA Today's coverage links to us with a followed link.

"The best and worst McDonald's in America, ranked by 20M reviews." Our own data study, October 2026.
- Yahoo NewsIndiana BMV offices ranked nation's best in analysis of reviewsOur own study, October 2026
- AOLThis Subway shop in the Central Valley is one of the highest ranked in nationOur own study, October 2026
- WTOK, MississippiThis is the worst-rated McDonald's in the US. See why customers have reviewed it so poorlyOur own study, October 2026
The reporting made the value clear. We could see the target page, anchor logic, publisher fit, and what changed from month to month.
Questions
Questions about backlink quality.
Something we haven't covered? Book a call, or email info@seobacklinks.com and we usually reply within one business day.
How do I check the quality of a backlink?
Run the 12 checks on this page: four on the site itself, four on the sites it links to, and four on your link and its article. All you need is Google, a browser and Ahrefs or Semrush.
What makes a good backlink?
A high-quality backlink comes from a real site with real readers, on a topic close to yours, inside an article that Google has indexed. Authority scores help, but readers and relevance matter more.
What is a good DR or DA score for a backlink?
There is no safe number. Ahrefs' DR and Moz's DA are useful as a first filter, but sellers pump them up. A smaller site with real readers usually beats a high-scoring site nobody visits.
Can I check backlink quality without paid tools?
About half of it, yes. Searching Google, reading articles, checking author pages and looking at link tags cost nothing. Traffic, outgoing link wording and link growth need Ahrefs or Semrush, and one month of a basic plan is enough to check a seller's list.
What should I look for in a backlink checker tool?
Traffic estimates, a list of each site's outgoing links, a graph of referring domains over time, and exports. Ahrefs and Semrush do all four. Before you commit, test the tool on a few sites you already know well.
How do I check that a backlink I paid for is live?
Open the article, find your link, then search Google for the article's exact web address. If the page appears in Google and the link is in the article, it's live. Check again after a month, because some sellers remove links quietly.
How do I check hundreds of backlinks at once?
Export them to a spreadsheet, group them by site, and check each site rather than each link. Sort by traffic and outgoing links first, because sites with no traffic and links to many unrelated businesses fail fastest.
Can I use this as a backlink audit checklist?
Yes, for judging the sites that link to you. A full audit adds the steps around it: exporting every link, grouping them, and deciding what, if anything, to disavow. Our backlink audit guide covers those steps.
Is a nofollow link a red flag?
No. A nofollow or sponsored tag is the normal way sites mark some links, and big news sites use them often. The red flag is paying extra for followed links, or a seller who won't say which you'll get.
Should I disavow every link that fails?
No. Google ignores most bad links on its own, and disavowing too much can cut links that were helping. Save the disavow file for clear patterns, such as a batch of network sites from one seller, or links named in a manual action.
Start here
Get links that pass every check.
Send your website and the pages you want to rank. We'll show you a sample report, so you can see what we check on every link.